You were given your chance at the company. Someone hired you, trained you and entrusted you with responsibility. You have good colleagues and perhaps a boss who believed in you before you believed in yourself. Now you have another offer that is hard to turn down. Yet you hesitate. Can you really justify leaving?
This question preoccupies Henrik Bertelsen in my novels The Dollar Compass and Starting from Scratch. It is about work, but also gratitude, belonging and the fear of letting people down. Before we answer it, we need to clarify what loyalty actually means.
Loyalty is an obligation to show faithfulness and support towards someone or something. In working life, things immediately become more complicated. To whom do you owe loyalty? Your company, your boss, your colleagues or your own future? Usually, these considerations can coexist. Things become interesting when they pull in different directions. If we also include our obligations of loyalty to family, friends and society, conflicts become inevitable. In this article, I discuss only the individual’s relationship with the workplace.
The company always comes before the boss

In my view, loyalty within an employment relationship is owed first and foremost to the company. The boss carries out a task on the organisation’s behalf. The day they put their own interests ahead of the company’s, they can no longer expect their employees’ loyalty to follow.
That sounds simple. In practice, standing by it can take considerable courage. Your boss allocates tasks, assesses your performance, influences your pay and often has the final say when someone is dismissed. At the same time, many organisations protect their hierarchy and will therefore initially defend the boss when an employee raises concerns. You cannot assume that acting in the company’s interests will, in itself, protect you. Keeping quiet can therefore feel safer, even when you believe a decision is harming the company.
In Starting from Scratch, Henrik suggests that Printonix consider outsourcing development and production. The printer is causing problems, and he doubts the company can resolve them satisfactorily on its own. His proposal challenges both management’s vision of what the company should be and the responsible managers’ view of themselves. It also carries an uncomfortable judgement: perhaps their departments lack the necessary expertise.
Henrik first tries speaking to the managers individually. When the head of development in particular refuses to listen, he brings his criticism and controversial proposals into the management team’s discussions. The disagreement becomes harder to ignore, but also more personal. His colleagues must now respond to the criticism in front of one another.
As readers, we tend to see Henrik as the courageous employee because he turns out to be right. But what if he had been wrong? The same behaviour might then look like an overconfident sales director undermining colleagues whose expertise he did not understand well enough.
Confronting the issue takes courage, whatever the outcome. Whether it is also wise and fair is another question. Loyalty therefore also requires you to consider whether your own judgement might be wrong before demanding that others change course.
“You needn’t question my loyalty,” he says, “but I disagree.”
For me, that line captures something essential. Loyalty requires you to exercise your judgement. Sometimes the most loyal thing you can do is insist on a discussion your boss and colleagues would rather avoid.
How loyal is the company to you?

Before asking more of the employee, we should turn the question around. How long does the company owe you its loyalty?
A decent employer treats its employees fairly, even when money is tight. But even the most employee-friendly company may have to eliminate jobs. The willingness to preserve them can extend only as far as the money allows, or as long as there is a credible prospect of the financial situation improving.
Some companies offer generous severance packages. Others can do no more than honour the agreements already in place. Moreover, the management you trust today may have been replaced by tomorrow.
That does not make the relationship worthless. It makes it conditional. It therefore seems unreasonable to me to expect employees to feel a lasting moral debt while the company can continually adjust its staffing to suit its needs.
Gratitude does not bind you to a job

In The Dollar Compass, Henrik has much to thank Control Data for. He has learned his trade, been given opportunities and earned good money. As he prepares to change jobs, he feels he will be letting a lot of people down.
His boss, Karsten, takes a different view:
“You don’t owe us anything. You have to do what’s best for you.”
Karsten recognises that the employment relationship has been a collaboration. The company has given Henrik opportunities, and Henrik has contributed his efforts. Both have benefited.
You can be grateful for the years you have spent somewhere and still decide to spend the next ones elsewhere. Your gratitude does not disappear because you hand in your notice.
The colleagues you leave behind

Often, however, it is your colleagues who make the decision difficult. They will have to take over your tasks. Perhaps you are in the middle of a crisis that will temporarily become harder if you leave. Perhaps you persuaded some of them to join the company, or even hired them yourself.
You should take that responsibility seriously. Finish work where possible, arrange a proper handover and be honest about what remains to be done. But you cannot make your future depend on ensuring that your departure is never inconvenient.
In Starting from Scratch, Henrik experiences employees leaving his own team. Regional manager John wants to open a pub with his brother. Henrik is disappointed but respects the decision. When another regional manager, Eric, later wants to move on quickly, Henrik helps arrange a handover so he need not stay any longer than strictly necessary.
It is easy to defend the right to change jobs when the offer is on your own desk. A manager’s loyalty also shows in their ability to give others the same freedom.
When loyalty calls for resistance

There are, of course, difficult periods when staying and fighting makes sense. A bad month or a decision you disagree with does not necessarily make the workplace wrong for you. I would go so far as to say that every company, without exception, will face difficulties at some point. If you always leave as soon as things become serious, you also miss out on experience that could prove valuable later in your working life.
Helping turn a looming disaster into a success can be enriching, both professionally and personally. You learn about setting priorities, making decisions amid uncertainty and making collaboration work when everyone is under pressure. You also discover something about yourself: what can you withstand, where do you contribute most, and when does your judgement begin to fail?
Even crises that end in bankruptcy provide experience. You see how problems grow, which warnings are ignored, and how hope of the next order or a technical solution can keep a company going long after its foundations have begun to crumble. At the end of Starting from Scratch, Henrik has to acknowledge that his shares are worthless. The most valuable things he takes with him are what he has experienced and learned.
If you stay until the bitter end, you can later take a certain pride in saying you did not abandon ship until all hope was gone. That pride may be justified. But the real value lies in what you contributed and learned along the way. Staying can be a good choice for your own future without becoming an obligation.
But if management behaves unethically, misleads customers or ignores serious problems, loyalty requires you to respond. In Starting from Scratch, Henrik goes so far as to propose dismissing his entire department, himself included, while the product problems are resolved. He puts the company’s survival ahead of his own position.
That does not mean Henrik always sees clearly or acts rightly. He, too, is caught up in ambition and the desire for the project to succeed. That is precisely what makes his dilemma interesting: when does perseverance become self-deception?
My rule of thumb is that you should be one hundred per cent loyal for as long as you are employed. Do your job, bring problems into the open and treat others decently. That also applies while you are considering another offer or working out your notice.
Being loyal does not mean following every order, either. A decision does not become defensible simply because management has made it. If you can no longer stand behind what you are expected to do, you must speak up and consider leaving the job. Even if the timing is inconvenient for the company.
That loyalty does not prevent you from leaving. Most companies can find another employee. You have only your own working life, and you cannot hand responsibility for it over to your boss.
You owe the company a proper effort and a proper departure.
Your future, however, is your own.